Uh oh...

It appears that you're using a severely outdated version of Safari on Windows. Many features won't work correctly, and functionality can't be guaranteed. Please try viewing this website in Edge, Mozilla, Chrome, or another modern browser. Sorry for any inconvenience this may have caused!

Read More about this safari issue.
Northwest Fayetteville
Get directions
Northwest Homegrown 0

Natural Way Peanut Butter


New backpacks, supplies and outfits for the first day of school are “musts” when kicking off the school year. But the team at Fayetteville, Arkansas-based Natural Way Food Group might argue that the best back-to-school experience is synonymous with August and peanut butter.

Austin Simkins and his brother, Quinn live with an entrepreneurial mindset. After a family vacation visit to the Celestial Seasonings Tea Factory in Colorado, Austin was mesmerized by the making of natural food products. He knew someday he wanted to produce and manufacture a product.

While working on his MBA in Supply Chain Management, Austin connected with a class speaker. Jeff Amerine from Startup Junkie, also in Fayetteville, shared the company’s support for entrepreneurs and connection to government grant programs. Austin interned with the program and gained experience by attending meetings: learning everything from building business plans, pitching products and setting up local manufacturing. While he saw the struggles, he was still intrigued to start his own business.

Simultaneously, Quinn was interning for Tyson Foods in mergers and acquisitions. With a background and experience in accounting and finance, and as he learned more about corporate company procedures, the two were the perfect complement for trying a new idea.

Natural Way Peanut Butter

The first product the brothers sold together was a gourmet peanut butter cup called Poppers. “It was something I took to parties or events, and people always told me I should sell them. It just seemed like the obvious first choice.” People loved the treats and local in-person customers would purchase them over and over.

A second product, Chirpies, expanded at first by using a dehydrated cricket powder for added protein. The healthy candy saw some success with placement in 250 Walmart stores, but the face-to-face farmer’s market consumer just couldn’t get over the word “cricket.”

Growing up as runners, eating a wad of peanut butter for a quick protein recharge was a common practice for the Simkins brothers. As they worked on products and researched the ingredients they were using, redeveloping peanut butter seemed like the next best move.

Creating a healthier version of something already in their lifestyle seemed natural.

Many shelf-stable peanut butters use palm oil. The brothers found that palms are farmed mainly around the equator and, in production, are destroying the rainforest. Because they value sustainable products, they opted for a more easily accessible olive oil, like their mom used in her kitchen as they grew up. A familiar flavor for customers, the olive oil-based product took off.

Switching from candy to nut butter was a significant change, but with an agile mindset that easily pivots as the solution to their lack of experience, they built new relationships with buyers and relied on the clout of already having a successful product in the market. They could use learned experiences to save time and not make the same mistake twice.

Natural Way peanut butter products are made with olive oil and little to no added sugar. They are non-GMO verified, and gluten-free certified. The product has a “smudgy” texture, helping you feel like you are eating a more natural product. All ingredients are sourced in the United States, and all manufacturing and production occur in Fayetteville, the Simkins’ hometown.

Natural Way Peanut Butter
Photo used with permission from Natural Way food group

Where can you find Natural Way peanut butter? Locations include:

  • Online
  • Local NWA Farmer’s Markets
  • Whole Foods – Southwest Region, Arkansas, Texas and Oklahoma
  • Ozark Natural Foods – Fayetteville
  • Harps – across Arkansas
  • Sprouts – nationwide
  • Safeway – Seattle area
  • Albertson’s – Seattle area and Colorado
  • Central Market – Texas
  • Amazon
  • Military Commissaries – globally

What flavors do they sell?

  • Original | peanut and almond butter – no added sugar
  • Honey | peanut and almond butter
  • Chocolate | peanut and almond butter
  • Coffee | peanut butter
  • Gingerbread and Pumpkin | peanut butter – seasonal

Learn more about Natural Way peanut butter, its philosophy, history, and order products online.

Meet the

Learn more about .

A little about .

Keisha (Pittman) McKinney lives in South Arkansas with her husband and sweet Boxer, Bailey and one-year-old son! Keisha is passionate about connecting people and building community, seeking solutions to the everyday big and small things, and encouraging others through the mundane, hard, and typical that life often brings. She put her communications background to work as a former Non-profit Executive Director, college recruiter and fundraiser, and Digital Media Director at a large church in Northwest Arkansas. Now she is using all of those experiences through McKinney Media Solutions and her blog @bigpittstop which includes daily adventures, cooking escapades, #bigsisterchats, the social justice cases on her heart, and all that she is learning as a #boymom!

Read more stories by Keisha Pittman McKinney


Visit Keisha Pittman McKinney’s Website

Like this story? Read more from Keisha Pittman McKinney


Join the Conversation

Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Submit a photo

We select one featured photo per week, but we show many more in our gallery. Be sure to fill out all the fields in order to have yours selected.

  • Accepted file types: jpg, png, Max. file size: 5 MB.

Regions Topics

What are you looking for?

Explore Arkansas

Central Arkansas

Little Rock, Conway, Searcy, Benton, Heber Springs

Northwest Arkansas

Fayetteville, Bentonville, Springdale, Fort Smith

South Arkansas

Hot Springs, Pine Bluff, Texarkana, Arkadelphia

Explore by Topic