Legendary Pitcher Ray Caldwell Joins the Travelers
In 1920, the Little Rock Travelers finally brought the Southern...
It appears that you're using a severely outdated version of Safari on Windows. Many features won't work correctly, and functionality can't be guaranteed. Please try viewing this website in Edge, Mozilla, Chrome, or another modern browser. Sorry for any inconvenience this may have caused!
Read More about this safari issue.In 1920, the Little Rock Travelers finally brought the Southern Association pennant to Arkansas. A fiery manager named Kid Elberfeld was the toast of the town, and a veteran lefty from White County became a local hero. The franchise took 20 years to reach the top of the standings and fill the stands with enthusiastic fans, but the good times would not last long.
In the pennant-winning year of 1920, the Travelers drew 165,000 fans. After two fourth-place finishes and two consecutive last-place disasters, the hapless 1924 Travs lost 101 games, and attendance fell to just over 50,000. The free-fall cost the once-popular Kid Elberfeld his job and triggered a roster purge that left only Rube Robinson safe from the locker cleanout.
The situation had become so desperate that the Travs proudly publicized the signing of a 37-year-old ex-major-leaguer named Ray Caldwell. In a bold headline, the Arkansas Gazette announced that the notorious pitcher and Mrs. Caldwell would join the Travelers immediately in Hot Springs.
Every fan with even casual baseball knowledge had heard of Ray Caldwell. He had won 134 big-league games, and his lifetime ERA with the Yankees, Red Sox and Indians was an excellent 3.22. Caldwell was famous by early 20th-century baseball standards, but most of his notoriety did not come from his pitching. Perhaps the most amazing thing about Raymond Benjamin Caldwell was that he was still alive.
The Gazette failed to mention that the 37-year-old veteran had numerous suspensions for a drinking problem, several mysterious unexcused absences and numerous fines for “irregular behavior” and various off-the-field “escapades.” Like many baseball stars of his day, a career in Major League Baseball meant money in Caldwell’s pocket and time on his hands. He had no experience with either.
His last years in the major leagues were with the Cleveland Indians, managed by former Travelers’ center fielder Tris Speaker. Tris had developed a strategy that had saved Caldwell’s career and made him a 20-game winner in Cleveland. It seems Speaker not only allowed Caldwell to drink excessively, but also mandated it. The only stipulation was that he get drunk only the evening after the game. He could take the next day off to recuperate before returning for three days that he was sober enough to pitch. Caldwell went 20 and 10 in 1920, but by 1921, even the “Speaker plan” did not make Ray Caldwell worth the disciplinary baggage that accompanied him.
Tales of Caldwell’s indiscretions followed him to the minor leagues, where he spent the four years before coming to Little Rock, but his big-league career and sordid record of misbehavior were not his most significant claim to fame. Ray Caldwell’s lasting notoriety would be earned on one hot summer day in 1919.
On Aug. 24, 1919, Cleveland had just signed the veteran pitcher for help during the last month of the pennant drive. Many baseball writers thought it was Caldwell’s last chance to overcome his reputation and stay in the big leagues. A lot was at stake, but a pennant race and a pitcher trying to salvage his career did not turn out to be the big story.
Although it was an unusually hot and humid August afternoon, the weatherman had predicted showers would arrive and cool the late-summer air. Perhaps an isolated thunderstorm would be part of the weather change.
Ray Caldwell got the starting assignment, and the Indians’ new pitcher was masterful. He looked every bit like the great pitcher he had been early in his career, and the Cleveland fans were solidly behind him as he entered the top of the ninth clinging to a 2–1 lead. The sky had darkened ominously in the last few minutes, and Caldwell worked fast. The wily veteran got two quick popouts as a fast-moving storm quickly engulfed the stadium.
Suddenly, a blinding flash lit up the dark afternoon, and a lightning bolt drilled down into League Park, accompanied by a deafening clap of thunder. Patrons ran for cover, and players on the field dove face down where they were. Witnesses claimed to have seen shards of visible electric current spring up in various spots on the field. Horror gripped what was left of the 20,000 in attendance as they gazed down at the players lying motionless on the playing field.
Gradually, one by one, the players took stock of themselves and clamored to their feet. All except pitcher Ray Caldwell, who remained face down on the mound. Cautious teammates approached their pitcher, expecting the worst.
Finally, Caldwell stirred, sat up, and clamored to his feet. All present agreed that small trails of smoke rose from a black spot on his chest, but the pitcher refused to leave the mound. “Ray just got up, shook his head a couple of times, like a steer that has been kissed by a locomotive, and barked at Ray Chapman, ‘Give me that danged ball and turn me toward home plate.’”
When everyone had sufficiently recovered, Jumpin’ Joe Dugan strolled tentatively to the plate with a drizzle still falling. Although most attendees had headed for the exits or huddled under the bleachers, thousands would later claim they saw Dugan ground out to end the game.
The incredible story of Caldwell’s recovery has lasted over 100 years and been retold and rewritten hundreds of times. The events of that August day remain one of those tales that only seem to happen in baseball. Ray Chapman was struck by lightning and lived to finish the game.
Chapman became a 20-game winner the next year, but by the time he came to Little Rock, he was 37, and his best years were behind him. He remained with the Travelers for parts of three seasons, winning 35 games while losing 54. The Travelers continued to finish last in the Southern Association.
Caldwell hung on in baseball until age 45. America was in the throes of the Great Depression, and he had to make a living. Ray Caldwell died of cancer in Salamanca, New York, on Aug. 19, 1967.
Sign up for our weekly e-news.
Get stories sent straight to your inbox!
Like this story? Read more from Jim Yeager
Nicknames are an integral part of professional baseball culture and one...
In the spring of 1979, baseball at the University of Arkansas was far...
The Arkansas Travelers closed their 2006 season on September 3, with a...
Join the Conversation
Leave a Comment